In November 2023, India’s Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (MIB) introduced the draft Broadcasting Services (Regulation) Bill, 2023, aiming to overhaul the existing regulatory framework for broadcasting services. This proposed legislation sought to replace the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act of 1995, encompassing a broader range of platforms and technologies, including over-the-top (OTT) platforms and digital news broadcasters.
Key Features of the Draft Bill
The draft bill proposed several significant changes:
- Establishment of the Broadcasting Authority of India (BAI): A new regulatory body intended to oversee the implementation of the bill and related regulations.
- Inclusion of Digital News Broadcasters: The bill introduced the term “digital news broadcasters,” encompassing individuals and entities producing online news and current affairs content, such as newsletters, social media posts, podcasts, and videos. This broad definition raised concerns about non-traditional media creators being subjected to similar obligations as traditional broadcasting platforms.
- Content Evaluation Committee (CEC): The bill proposed the formation of a committee responsible for evaluating content and certifying its compliance with established codes. This measure aimed to address issues like hate speech, fake news, and violence through content codes and age verification mechanisms.
- Data Localization: Certain platforms would be required to store data within India, raising concerns about privacy and potential misuse of information.
Pros of the Proposed Bill
- Unified Regulatory Framework: By consolidating various broadcasting services under a single framework, the bill aimed to streamline regulations, potentially leading to more efficient governance.
- Content Accountability: The introduction of content evaluation mechanisms sought to hold platforms accountable for harmful content, addressing issues like misinformation and hate speech.
- Promotion of Local Content: The bill emphasized increasing the presence of Indian programming across all platforms, potentially boosting local content creation and cultural representation.
Cons and Controversies
- Potential Overreach: The expansive definitions within the bill, particularly concerning digital news broadcasters, could subject individual content creators and influencers to stringent regulations, potentially stifling creative expression.
- Ambiguity in Content Codes: The vague nature of content codes and the subjective interpretation of what constitutes harmful content raised concerns about arbitrary enforcement and suppression of dissenting voices.
- Privacy Concerns: Data localization requirements and government access to user data sparked fears about privacy violations and potential misuse of information.
Debate on Freedom of Speech and Expression
Critics argued that the bill’s provisions could infringe upon the fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression. The broad regulatory powers granted to the government were seen as a potential tool for censorship, suppressing free expression under the guise of content regulation. The inclusion of digital content creators under the bill’s ambit could deter individuals from producing content, fearing legal repercussions, thereby stifling innovation and diversity in digital media.
Recent Developments
In July 2024, the MIB circulated a revised draft of the bill among select stakeholders. However, facing criticism over transparency and potential overreach, the ministry withdrew the draft in August 2024, stating plans for further consultations with stakeholders. As of October 2024, reports indicated that the rework on the second draft had been suspended, and no stakeholder consultations were planned in the near future.
Conclusion
The Broadcasting Services (Regulation) Bill, 2023, represented a significant attempt to modernize India’s broadcasting regulations in the digital age. While aiming to create a unified regulatory framework and promote accountability, the bill faced substantial criticism over potential infringements on freedom of speech and expression, as well as concerns about government overreach. The withdrawal and suspension of the draft bill underscore the complexities involved in balancing regulation with fundamental rights in the rapidly evolving digital landscape.
Source credits: https://sabrangindia.in/broadcasting-bill-adverse-to-freedom-of-speech-freedom-of-press-egi/
More Current Affairs: https://learnproacademy.in/updates/